Skip to content
  • CAREERS
  • CONTACT US
Search
Close
anthony ostlund logo
  • PEOPLE
  • LITIGATION
    • APPEALS
    • COMPLEX COMMERCIAL LITIGATION
    • EMPLOYMENT LITIGATION
    • FRAUD AND FIDUCIARY DUTY
    • FINANCIAL LITIGATION
    • OWNER/SHAREHOLDER DISPUTES
    • PLAINTIFF CONTINGENCY CASES
    • PROFESSIONAL MALPRACTICE
    • REAL ESTATE LITIGATION
    • TRUSTS AND ESTATES LAW
  • SUCCESSES
  • NEWS
  • ABOUT
  • FEE ARRANGEMENTS
Menu
  • PEOPLE
  • LITIGATION
    • APPEALS
    • COMPLEX COMMERCIAL LITIGATION
    • EMPLOYMENT LITIGATION
    • FRAUD AND FIDUCIARY DUTY
    • FINANCIAL LITIGATION
    • OWNER/SHAREHOLDER DISPUTES
    • PLAINTIFF CONTINGENCY CASES
    • PROFESSIONAL MALPRACTICE
    • REAL ESTATE LITIGATION
    • TRUSTS AND ESTATES LAW
  • SUCCESSES
  • NEWS
  • ABOUT
  • FEE ARRANGEMENTS

The Ten Commandments of Cross-Examination in FINRA Hearings

  • November 4, 2019
November 4, 2019
Minnesota Lawyer and Finance & Commerce – Partner Content
Author: Peter J. McElligott

Decades ago, Irving Younger gave us the Ten Commandments of Cross-Examination.
If you have not seen it, do a quick search for the impassioned presentation and you will not be disappointed. As an experienced trial lawyer, Professor Younger developed these Commandments from his experience in dozens jury trials. Drawing on my own experiences trying cases in a different forum, I’d like to offer some amendments to Professor Younger’s original Commandments when used in a particular setting: FINRA arbitration hearings.
Most disputes between investors, financial advisors, and broker-dealers are resolved in arbitration under the guidance of the self-regulatory body called the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (“FINRA”). Like other arbitral forums, FINRA has its own set of procedural rules known as the FINRA Code of Arbitration Procedure. The FINRA Code has some significant differences from federal and state rules of civil procedure. First, the FINRA Code severely limits dispositive motions. There are no motions for summary judgment. While parties can bring motions to dismiss in limited circumstances, those motions are infrequently granted. Second, discovery is significantly limited. Parties generally cannot conduct depositions or request interrogatories. This causes a great deal of uncertainty and makes preparing for cross-examination more difficult. With these differences in mind, let’s review Professor Younger’s Ten Commandments (in bold below) and modify them for FINRA arbitration hearings.
1. Be Brief. This is good advice in any forum, but especially FINRA hearings. With limited discovery and very little motion practice, each additional question is a venture into the unknown. Make your critical points and get out. This is particularly true when cross-examining investors. Little can be gained from humiliating (or trying and failing to humiliate) an investor alleging they lost money because of bad advice.
2. Use Plain Words. This commandment is particularly important in FINRA arbitrations, which may involve complex financial products that need to be boiled down. Simplify as much as possible, especially when cross-examining investors.
3. Use Only Leading Questions. Even when you do not know the answer, leading questions limit surprise answers and witness explanations.
4. Be Prepared (a.k.a. never ask a question you do not know the answer to). In FINRA, it is very hard to avoid this because you never know what a witness is going to say. Depositions and interrogatories allow the parties to flush out what the opposing side is going to say at trial. Without them as part of discovery, there are inevitably going to be some surprises at a FINRA hearing. When those surprises happen, be prepared to take advantage (the testimony may be a good surprise), to limit damage, or to move on.
5. Listen. This commandment is even more important in FINRA hearings because of the uncertainty of answers. If a witness provides an unexpected answer, you have to listen so you can follow up with leading questions that limit damage or circle back to your ultimate point.
6. Do Not Quarrel. If the statement is so absurd the arbitrators recognize its absurdity, follow this rule. If not, tread carefully. Without the benefit of depositions to practice answering questions under oath, effective cross-examiners can push and prod novice, over-confident witnesses so they lose credibility in front of the arbitrators.
7. Avoid Repetition. Often times, the arbitrators are experienced with FINRA rules and regulations, the nature of the issues, and the investment products involved. At the same time, repetition can be a useful tool in FINRA hearings because repetition shows that a witness’s actions were not a mistake.
8. Disallow Witness Explanation. Sometimes this cannot be avoided. Arbitrators are often lax in holding witnesses’ feet to the fire. Don’t fret. Follow up on explanatory statements by limiting the explanation to a simple point.
9. Limit Questioning. This advice holds up equally in FINRA hearings and jury trials. Don’t give the witness a chance to escape by asking one question too many.
10. Save for Summation. Although tempting, avoid the final question that ties your case together. Instead, use cross-examination to establish building blocks that you can use for the foundation of closing argument when you have more time to prepare. This is especially true in FINRA hearings where attorneys generally have more latitude to be argumentative.
As Professor Younger stated, these are not suggestions. “They are Commandments! You must comply with them.” If you do not comply, you (or your clients in a FINRA arbitration hearing) will regret it.

 

related attorneys

Loading...

Peter J. McElligott

related practice areas

Loading...
AO-logo-initials

90 SOUTH 7TH STREET, SUITE 3600
MINNEAPOLIS, MN 55402
P 612.349.6969       F 612.349.6996

 

© 2021 ANTHONY OSTLUND LOUWAGIE DRESSEN BOYLAN P.A.
ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

  • 651•312•6500
  • 651•312•6618
  • People
  • Litigation
  • Successes
  • News
  • About
  • Fee Arrangements
  • Careers
  • Contact
Menu
  • People
  • Litigation
  • Successes
  • News
  • About
  • Fee Arrangements
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • PEOPLE
  • LITIGATION
    • APPEALS
    • COMPLEX COMMERCIAL LITIGATION
    • EMPLOYMENT LITIGATION
    • FRAUD AND FIDUCIARY DUTY
    • FINANCIAL LITIGATION
    • OWNER/SHAREHOLDER DISPUTES
    • PLAINTIFF CONTINGENCY CASES
    • PROFESSIONAL MALPRACTICE
    • REAL ESTATE LITIGATION
    • TRUSTS AND ESTATES LAW
  • SUCCESSES
  • NEWS
  • ABOUT
  • FEE ARRANGEMENTS
Menu
  • PEOPLE
  • LITIGATION
    • APPEALS
    • COMPLEX COMMERCIAL LITIGATION
    • EMPLOYMENT LITIGATION
    • FRAUD AND FIDUCIARY DUTY
    • FINANCIAL LITIGATION
    • OWNER/SHAREHOLDER DISPUTES
    • PLAINTIFF CONTINGENCY CASES
    • PROFESSIONAL MALPRACTICE
    • REAL ESTATE LITIGATION
    • TRUSTS AND ESTATES LAW
  • SUCCESSES
  • NEWS
  • ABOUT
  • FEE ARRANGEMENTS
search
disclaimer
Linkedin
Join Our Email List

© 2021 ANTHONY OSTLUND LOUWAGIE DRESSEN BOYLAN P.A. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Cookie settingsACCEPT
Privacy & Cookies Policy

Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these cookies, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may have an effect on your browsing experience.
Necessary
Always Enabled
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Non-necessary
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.
SAVE & ACCEPT